Amara Cay Resort
What Makes This Hotel Stand Out
Its combination of beachfront access, comprehensive amenities like bike rentals and a water taxi, and a strong emphasis on friendly, accommodating staff creates a memorable family experience in the Keys.
Parent Pro Tip
Request a room away from elevators or high-traffic areas for quieter sleep, especially for younger children. Consider the suite options for added space and comfort.
Why Families Love This Hotel
Families love this hotel for its beachfront access, pool, bike rentals, and spacious suites. Great for exploring the Keys with helpful staff and fun amenities.
Amara Cay Resort offers a family-friendly experience with good amenities and a prime Keys location, though occasional issues with room condition and beach access should be considered.
Best for: Families seeking a vibrant Keys experience with a blend of relaxation and activities, particularly those who enjoy water sports and exploring local attractions.
At a Glance
The resort offers good value, especially considering its beachfront location and available amenities, though some guests...
Room Setup
The resort offers suites which are well-suited for families, with some featuring a separate bedroom and living area with a pull-out couch.
Kids Features
The resort boasts a beautiful pool with a view and a heated option.
Family Dining
The on-site restaurant receives mixed reviews, with some finding it good and others mentioning limited options or closures for remodeling.
Location
The hotel is well-positioned for exploring the Florida Keys, with easy access to biking to nearby restaurants and attractions.
Map Location — Amara Cay Resort
80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036-3802
While the resort has a pool and some activities, the direct ocean access via stairs and limited dedicated toddler amenities make it less ideal for the youngest travelers.
Detailed Family Analysis for Amara Cay Resort
Our AI has analyzed 50 family reviews to give you detailed insights about what makes this hotel great for families.
🏆 Overall Family Assessment
Amara Cay Resort offers a family-friendly experience with good amenities and a prime Keys location, though occasional issues with room condition and beach access should be considered.
🏨 Room Setup & Space
The resort offers suites which are well-suited for families, with some featuring a separate bedroom and living area with a pull-out couch. While some rooms are described as spacious, a few reviews mention they could use updating.
🎯 Kids' Amenities
The resort boasts a beautiful pool with a view and a heated option. While there are mentions of yard games on the beach, specific dedicated children's play areas or kids' clubs are not highlighted.
🍽️ Family Dining
The on-site restaurant receives mixed reviews, with some finding it good and others mentioning limited options or closures for remodeling. Some reviews mention 'Kids Meals' as an amenity.
✨ Cleanliness & Safety
Generally, rooms are reported as spotless and grounds are immaculate in positive reviews. However, a few negative reviews mention cleanliness issues such as odors and debris under furniture.
📍 Location & Attractions
The hotel is well-positioned for exploring the Florida Keys, with easy access to biking to nearby restaurants and attractions. The Rum Runner water taxi also provides convenient transport.
💡 Practical Tips
Check-in experiences are varied, with some guests encountering delays or issues with room assignments. However, many highlight exceptionally helpful and friendly staff, with specific shout-outs to individuals.
⚠️ Things to Consider
Some guests noted that the 'beach' is not a traditional sandy beach but has steps to enter the water, which can be concerning for families with young children. Room upkeep and outdated furnishings are also mentioned by some.
Hotel Amenities
✨Other Amenities(41)
🏊Pool & Water(12)
🛎️Services(8)
Browse more family hotels by amenity
Family Activities Near Amara Cay Resort
Kid-friendly attractions and things to do nearby
Theater of the Sea
A marine life attraction offering dolphin and sea lion shows, and opportunities to swim with dolphins.
Robbie's of Islamorada
Famous for feeding the tarpon, this spot also offers boat tours and fishing charters.
Rain Barrel Village
A collection of unique shops and art galleries, with some family-friendly artisan crafts.
History of Diving Museum
Explore the fascinating history of underwater exploration with exhibits that can engage older children.
Anne's Beach
A shallow, family-friendly beach with calm waters, perfect for little ones.
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions from families about Amara Cay Resort
Are cribs or highchairs available for families with infants?▼
What is the beach like at Amara Cay Resort?▼
Can families with larger groups or multiple children stay comfortably?▼
Is there kid-friendly dining on-site?▼
What activities are available for families with school-aged children?▼
More Family Hotels in Islamorada
Explore other top-rated family-friendly hotels nearby
Cheeca Lodge & Spa
Families love Cheeca Lodge for its beautiful grounds, excellent amenities like pools and kids' activities, and exceptionally friendly staff. It's a perfect escape with plenty to do.
Based on 50 reviews (16 family reviews)
Islander Resort
Families rave about the Islander Resort for its plentiful activities, beachfront access, and family-friendly staff. It offers a relaxing tropical vibe with renovated rooms and great amenities for all ages.
Based on 50 reviews (16 family reviews)
Ragged Edge Resort & Marina
Families love this hotel for its immaculate rooms, beachfront access, and complimentary amenities like kayaks and bikes. It offers a relaxed vibe with helpful staff and well-equipped kitchenettes, making it a great base for exploring the Keys.
Based on 50 reviews (12 family reviews)
La Jolla Resort
Families adore La Jolla Resort for its free water sports, spacious rooms, and prime location near restaurants. It offers a relaxing atmosphere with plenty of activities for all ages.
Based on 50 reviews (7 family reviews)
Pines and Palms Resort
Families love Pines and Palms Resort for its beachfront access, complimentary water sports like kayaking and paddleboarding, spacious and clean rooms, and friendly, accommodating staff. It's a perfect spot for relaxation and fun.
Based on 50 reviews (9 family reviews)
Sands of Islamorada Hotel
Clean rooms, waterfront views, and a relaxing atmosphere make this hotel a good choice for families. Key amenities include a pool and kitchenette options.
Based on 50 reviews (14 family reviews)