
Amara Cay Resort
What Makes This Hotel Stand Out
The resort fee includes shuttle service and partner property access, and guests enjoyed riding the Rum Runner water taxi, borrowing bikes to reach nearby restaurants, and fishing from the property.
Parent Pro Tip
One family with three kids under 5 booked a 1-bedroom suite and found its bedroom, with no balcony or windows, great for the kids' sleep, while the adults used the living-room balcony and pull-out couch. Separately, a reviewer reported a worn-out sofa-bed mattress, so check it on arrival and ask for a fix right away.
Why Families Love This Hotel
Families love this hotel because: a heated, fenced outdoor pool, free cribs, bikes and the Rum Runner water taxi for exploring, and 1-bedroom suites with a sofa bed.
Amara Cay Resort offers a family-friendly experience with good amenities and a prime Keys location, though occasional issues with room condition and beach access should be considered.
Best for: Families seeking a vibrant Keys experience with a blend of relaxation and activities, particularly those who enjoy water sports and exploring local attractions.
At a Glance
Value opinions are mixed: some guests found the price and USD 73.13-per-night mandatory resort fee worthwhile for the pool, staff and included extras, while several others felt rooms were tired or small for what they paid.
Room Setup
The resort offers suites which are well-suited for families, with some featuring a separate bedroom and living area with a pull-out couch.
Kids Features
The resort boasts a beautiful pool with a view and a heated option.
Family Dining
The on-site restaurant receives mixed reviews, with some finding it good and others mentioning limited options or closures for remodeling.
Location
The hotel is well-positioned for exploring the Florida Keys, with easy access to biking to nearby restaurants and attractions.
Map Location — Amara Cay Resort
80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036-3802
While the resort has a pool and some activities, the direct ocean access via stairs and limited dedicated toddler amenities make it less ideal for the youngest travelers.
Detailed Family Analysis for Amara Cay Resort
Our AI has analyzed 50 family reviews to give you detailed insights about what makes this hotel great for families.
🏆 Overall Family Assessment
Amara Cay Resort offers a family-friendly experience with good amenities and a prime Keys location, though occasional issues with room condition and beach access should be considered.
🏨 Room Setup & Space
The resort offers suites which are well-suited for families, with some featuring a separate bedroom and living area with a pull-out couch. While some rooms are described as spacious, a few reviews mention they could use updating.
🎯 Kids' Amenities
The resort boasts a beautiful pool with a view and a heated option. While there are mentions of yard games on the beach, specific dedicated children's play areas or kids' clubs are not highlighted.
🍽️ Family Dining
The on-site restaurant receives mixed reviews, with some finding it good and others mentioning limited options or closures for remodeling. Some reviews mention 'Kids Meals' as an amenity.
✨ Cleanliness & Safety
Generally, rooms are reported as spotless and grounds are immaculate in positive reviews. However, a few negative reviews mention cleanliness issues such as odors and debris under furniture.
📍 Location & Attractions
The hotel is well-positioned for exploring the Florida Keys, with easy access to biking to nearby restaurants and attractions. The Rum Runner water taxi also provides convenient transport.
💡 Practical Tips
Check-in experiences are varied, with some guests encountering delays or issues with room assignments. However, many highlight exceptionally helpful and friendly staff, with specific shout-outs to individuals.
⚠️ Things to Consider
Some guests noted that the 'beach' is not a traditional sandy beach but has steps to enter the water, which can be concerning for families with young children. Room upkeep and outdated furnishings are also mentioned by some.
Hotel Amenities
✨Other Amenities(41)
🏊Pool & Water(12)
🛎️Services(8)
Browse more family hotels by amenity
Family Activities Near Amara Cay Resort
Kid-friendly attractions and things to do nearby
Theater of the Sea
A marine life attraction offering dolphin and sea lion shows, and opportunities to swim with dolphins.
Robbie's of Islamorada
Famous for feeding the tarpon, this spot also offers boat tours and fishing charters.
Rain Barrel Village
A collection of unique shops and art galleries, with some family-friendly artisan crafts.
History of Diving Museum
Explore the fascinating history of underwater exploration with exhibits that can engage older children.
Anne's Beach
A shallow, family-friendly beach with calm waters, perfect for little ones.
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions from families about Amara Cay Resort
Are cribs available?▼
Is there a resort fee?▼
Is breakfast included?▼
Is the beach safe for young kids?▼
What are check-in and check-out times?▼
More Family Hotels in Islamorada
Explore other top-rated family-friendly hotels nearby

Cheeca Lodge & Spa
Families love this hotel because: a free children's club, 3 outdoor pools, a beach sandbox for toddlers, and a pier where kids 7+ can fish with an adult.
Based on 50 reviews (16 family reviews)

Islander Resort
Families love this hotel because: 2 outdoor pools, mini golf, on-site kayaks and paddleboards, rooms with private patios, and free cribs.
Based on 50 reviews (16 family reviews)

Ragged Edge Resort & Marina
Families love this hotel because: spotlessly clean rooms, kitchen setups for easy in-room meals, a fenced heated pool with a view, fishing off the pier, and quiet grounds with hammocks and grills.
Based on 50 reviews (12 family reviews)

La Jolla Resort
Families love this hotel because: kayaks, paddle boards, bikes & fishing poles come included; up to 2 kids 10 & under stay free; in-room kitchenettes; a fenced outdoor pool; restaurants within walking distance.
Based on 50 reviews (7 family reviews)

Pines and Palms Resort
Families love this hotel because: free kayaks, paddleboards, bikes and fishing gear; beachfront with a fenced, heated pool; kitchenettes; renovated cottages; small, quiet property with attentive staff.
Based on 50 reviews (9 family reviews)

Sands of Islamorada Hotel
Families love this hotel because: rooms have a kitchenette with fridge and microwave, there's a fenced outdoor pool, the waterfront has lounge chairs and a hammock, BBQ grills are on site, and cribs and rollaways are free.
Based on 50 reviews (14 family reviews)