The Lightkeepers Inn - Photo 1
1 / 20
+15

The Lightkeepers Inn

Martha's Vineyard, MA • 25 Simpsons Ln PO Box 488, Edgartown, Martha's Vineyard, MA 02539-8149
⭐

What Makes This Hotel Stand Out

Rooms are apartment-style suites with a separate bedroom, a living room with sofa bed and a kitchenette, which families with kids said made the stay easy, all on a quiet street a short walk from downtown Edgartown.

💡

Parent Pro Tip

Reserve your parking spot with the inn before you arrive, since onsite parking is limited to one space per unit and costs USD 50 per night. Two reviewers noted that cars waiting for the Chappy ferry line up on the inn's street, so leave extra time when you need to drive out.

Why Families Love This Hotel

Families love this hotel because: suites with kitchenettes and separate living rooms, sofa beds for kids, an easy walk to Edgartown shops, restaurants and ice cream, beach chairs and towels provided, and very clean rooms

The Lightkeepers Inn is a highly recommended choice for families seeking a comfortable, clean, and conveniently located stay on Martha's Vineyard. Its suite-style accommodations with kitchenettes and excellent proximity to local attractions make it a practical and enjoyable option.

Best for: Ideal for families seeking a comfortable, self-catering stay in a prime Edgartown location.

At a Glance

Family Score
8.8
AI-Powered
Out of 10
4.8
50 ratings
👨‍👩‍👧‍👦All Ages
Best For
$350+/night
Luxury
💰good Value

Several guests describe the rates as reasonable for Martha's Vineyard, especially off season, and in-suite kitchens can cut dining costs, but budget for paid parking (USD 50 per night), crib (USD 50 per day) or rollaway (USD 100 per day) fees, and no included breakfast (noted by one reviewer).

🏨

Room Setup

The Lightkeepers Inn offers a variety of suite and cottage options, many featuring separate living areas and bedrooms, which are ideal for families needing space.

🎯

Kids Features

While specific kids' amenities like a pool or playground are not mentioned, the inn provides family-friendly room setups and kitchenettes.

🍽️

Family Dining

The presence of kitchenettes and full kitchens in many suites is a major advantage for families, allowing for meal preparation and saving on dining costs.

📍

Location

The inn boasts an excellent, central location in Edgartown, within easy walking distance to shops, restaurants, the waterfront, and even the Chappy ferry.

Map Location — The Lightkeepers Inn

25 Simpsons Ln PO Box 488, Edgartown, Martha's Vineyard, MA 02539-8149

Scroll to load map
Best For:
toddlersschool-ageteensmulti-gen

The suites with kitchenettes and separate living areas cater well to families of various ages, offering space and convenience for younger children and privacy for older ones.

Detailed Family Analysis for The Lightkeepers Inn

Our AI has analyzed 50 family reviews to give you detailed insights about what makes this hotel great for families.

🏆 Overall Family Assessment

The Lightkeepers Inn is a highly recommended choice for families seeking a comfortable, clean, and conveniently located stay on Martha's Vineyard. Its suite-style accommodations with kitchenettes and excellent proximity to local attractions make it a practical and enjoyable option.

🏨 Room Setup & Space

The Lightkeepers Inn offers a variety of suite and cottage options, many featuring separate living areas and bedrooms, which are ideal for families needing space. Some suites include pull-out sofa beds, accommodating larger families. The small house (Room 6) is noted as comfortable for up to five people, though it is considered the maximum size.

🎯 Kids' Amenities

While specific kids' amenities like a pool or playground are not mentioned, the inn provides family-friendly room setups and kitchenettes. Bicycle rentals and proximity to beaches and outdoor activities are highlighted, offering opportunities for family fun.

🍽️ Family Dining

The presence of kitchenettes and full kitchens in many suites is a major advantage for families, allowing for meal preparation and saving on dining costs. This is ideal for families with young children or those preferring to have more control over their meals.

✨ Cleanliness & Safety

Cleanliness is consistently praised across all reviews, with guests repeatedly describing the accommodations as 'spotless' and 'immaculately clean.' This high standard of cleanliness is a significant factor contributing to families' comfort and peace of mind during their stay.

📍 Location & Attractions

The inn boasts an excellent, central location in Edgartown, within easy walking distance to shops, restaurants, the waterfront, and even the Chappy ferry. This proximity allows families to explore the area conveniently without the need for a car.

💡 Practical Tips

On-site parking is a highly valued amenity, especially given parking limitations in Edgartown. Staff are frequently mentioned as being helpful and accommodating, contributing to a smooth and pleasant check-in and stay.

⚠️ Things to Consider

One reviewer mentioned a significant bug issue in their room, suggesting a potential problem with seals or entry points. The inn's location in Edgartown is noted as being several miles from the ferry terminal, which might be a consideration for some travelers, though Edgartown itself is described as quieter than peak season areas.

Hotel Amenities

✨Other Amenities(50)

InternetSuitesFree InternetNon-smoking roomsAir conditioningMicrowaveRefrigerator in roomNon-smoking hotelGolf courseFlatscreen TVHousekeepingBaggage StorageBath / ShowerBathrobesBBQ FacilitiesBicycle RentalBoatingBowling Off-siteCable / Satellite TV24-Hour Check-inExpress Check-in / Check-outCoffee / Tea MakerDeskDivingEnglishFishingComplimentary ToiletriesGermanHair DryerHighchairs AvailableHikingIronOutdoor FurnitureOvenPortuguesePrivate BathroomsPrivate Check-in / Check-outRadioSeating AreaSnorkelingSofaSofa BedStovetopSun TerraceSun UmbrellasTelephoneUmbrellaWake Up Service / Alarm ClockWardrobe / ClosetWindsurfing

🏊Pool & Water(4)

BeachfrontSun Loungers / Beach ChairsWater Sport Equipment RentalsBeach Access

🍽️Dining(3)

KitchenetteDining AreaKitchenware

Family Activities Near The Lightkeepers Inn

Kid-friendly attractions and things to do nearby

🏰

Edgartown Lighthouse

0.4 mi

A picturesque lighthouse offering scenic views and a pleasant walk.

FreeOutdoor
🏖️

South Beach

3.5 mi

A popular and expansive beach known for its strong waves, great for surfing and sunbathing.

FreeOutdoor
⛰️

Chappaquiddick Island

0.5 mi

Accessible via ferry, offering beautiful natural landscapes and remote beaches.

Outdoor
📍

Morning Glory Farm

1.8 mi

A charming farm stand and market offering fresh produce and a taste of local life.

Indoor/Outdoor
📍

Ocean View Sports

1 mi

Offers rentals and activities like kayaking, paddleboarding, and windsurfing.

Outdoor
🏛️

Edgartown Historical Society

0.5 mi

Explore the rich history of Edgartown and Martha's Vineyard.

Indoor

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions from families about The Lightkeepers Inn

Are cribs available?▼
Yes, cribs/infant beds are available for USD 50 per day, and rollaway beds for USD 100 per day. Highchairs are also listed as available.
Is parking free?▼
No. Onsite self parking costs USD 50 per night, is limited to one space per unit, and must be reserved with the property in advance.
Will a family of five fit?▼
One family of two adults and three kids (ages 5-10) stayed in the small house (Room 6) and called it about the max for comfort. Families of four reported plenty of room in Suite #3 and Suite #4, which have a separate bedroom and a foldout couch.
Is breakfast included?▼
One reviewer noted the rate does not include breakfast, but suites have kitchenettes with a stovetop, microwave, refrigerator and coffee maker.
What are check-in and check-out times?▼
Check-in runs from 4:00 PM to 10:00 PM, and check-out is at 11:00 AM. Pets are not allowed.

More Family Hotels in Martha's Vineyard

Explore other top-rated family-friendly hotels nearby

Egyptian cotton sheets, premium bedding, pillowtop beds, desk, image
Babies/Tots
Best For

Faraway Martha's Vineyard

Martha's Vineyard, MA

Families love this hotel because: walkable Edgartown location by the harbor, free bikes to borrow, a heated saltwater pool plus hot tub, and suites with separate living rooms.

Based on 50 reviews (15 family reviews)

👶Kids Media🏊‍♀️Heated Pool🏊‍♀️Outdoor Pool
36-inch flat-screen TV with cable channels, TV, image
Babies/Tots
Best For

Harbor View Hotel

Martha's Vineyard, MA

Families love this hotel because: attentive service at the Bettini restaurant, a walkable location near Edgartown, a heated saltwater outdoor pool (May to October), connecting rooms on request, and free parking.

Based on 50 reviews (17 family reviews)

✨Family Rooms🏊‍♀️Heated Pool🏊‍♀️Outdoor Pool
Lobby lounge, image
Babies/Tots
Best For

Madison Inn

Martha's Vineyard, MA

Families love this hotel because: it's a short walk from the Oak Bluffs ferry, beach chairs, towels and umbrellas are free to borrow, and coffee, fruit, snacks and ice cream are out for guests.

Based on 50 reviews (25 family reviews)

Front of property - evening/night, image
Babies/Tots
Best For

Vineyard Square Hotel & Suites

Martha's Vineyard, MA

Families love this hotel because: walkable Edgartown location near shops and restaurants, breakfast included, free onsite parking (reserve ahead), bicycles available, and in-room refrigerators.

Based on 50 reviews (14 family reviews)

👶Kids Media🥐Breakfast Included✨Family Rooms
Beach nearby, image
Babies/Tots
Best For

Mansion House

Martha's Vineyard, MA

Families love this hotel because: an indoor pool that two reviewers say their kids loved, a rooftop deck, a short walk to the Vineyard Haven ferry, and interconnected rooms plus highchairs available.

Based on 50 reviews (12 family reviews)

✨Family Rooms🏊‍♀️Heated Pool🏊‍♀️Indoor Pool
Exterior, image
Babies/Tots
Best For

Pequot Hotel

Martha's Vineyard, MA

Families love this hotel because: free breakfast each morning, afternoon cookies and lemonade, beach chairs and towels to borrow, and an easy walk to the beach and Oak Bluffs town.

Based on 50 reviews (13 family reviews)

🥐Breakfast Included✨Family Rooms✨Suites
The Lightkeepers Inn
8.8 Score$350+/night

AI summaries and family ratings are generated by Hotels for Families. Always verify details directly with hotels before booking.