
Edgartown Commons
What Makes This Hotel Stand Out
It pairs a walkable spot near downtown Edgartown and the bus stop with apartment-style units that have kitchens and living space. Many reviewers are repeat guests, with several saying they have returned for 20 to 35 years, some bringing their children every summer.
Parent Pro Tip
The hotel offers no cribs, so pack a travel crib if you have an infant. One family of five said boogie boards, sand toys, beach chairs and a wagon were available, so ask before hauling your own beach gear.
Why Families Love This Hotel
Families love this hotel because: it's a short walk to downtown Edgartown, units have kitchens, there's a fenced outdoor pool plus a playground, and grills and picnic tables make easy family dinners.
Edgartown Commons is a highly-rated option for families seeking an affordable and conveniently located stay on Martha's Vineyard. Its suite-style accommodations and on-site amenities make it a practical choice, though potential guests should be aware of isolated negative feedback regarding specific units and management.
Best for: Ideal for families seeking a comfortable, convenient, and budget-friendly base for exploring Martha's Vineyard.
At a Glance
Several guests describe it as affordable or well priced for Martha's Vineyard, though one longtime guest is reconsidering returning because fees have increased.
Room Setup
Rooms range from studios to suites and family rooms, many featuring condominium-style layouts with kitchenettes.
Kids Features
The hotel offers a valuable playground on-site, which is frequently highlighted as a 'parent-saver.' The outdoor pool is also a significant draw, providing a fun and accessible place for children to cool off and play.
Family Dining
Many units come equipped with kitchenettes, including microwaves, refrigerators, stovetops, and ovens, allowing families to prepare their own meals and save money.
Location
Edgartown Commons boasts an ideal location within walking distance to downtown Edgartown's shops, restaurants, and attractions.
Map Location — Edgartown Commons
20 Peases Point Way N, Edgartown, Martha's Vineyard, MA 02539-8002
The playground and pool are perfect for younger children, while the proximity to town and beaches appeals to older children and teenagers. The kitchenette facilities are also beneficial for families with varied dietary needs.
Detailed Family Analysis for Edgartown Commons
Our AI has analyzed 50 family reviews to give you detailed insights about what makes this hotel great for families.
🏆 Overall Family Assessment
Edgartown Commons is a highly-rated option for families seeking an affordable and conveniently located stay on Martha's Vineyard. Its suite-style accommodations and on-site amenities make it a practical choice, though potential guests should be aware of isolated negative feedback regarding specific units and management.
🏨 Room Setup & Space
Rooms range from studios to suites and family rooms, many featuring condominium-style layouts with kitchenettes. This provides ample space, including separate living areas and sofa beds, making them suitable for families needing room to spread out.
🎯 Kids' Amenities
The hotel offers a valuable playground on-site, which is frequently highlighted as a 'parent-saver.' The outdoor pool is also a significant draw, providing a fun and accessible place for children to cool off and play.
🍽️ Family Dining
Many units come equipped with kitchenettes, including microwaves, refrigerators, stovetops, and ovens, allowing families to prepare their own meals and save money. This is a significant advantage for families with picky eaters or those looking for a more home-like dining experience.
✨ Cleanliness & Safety
The property generally receives high marks for cleanliness, with reviewers consistently mentioning clean and well-maintained units. Housekeeping is noted as being attentive, ensuring a comfortable stay for families.
📍 Location & Attractions
Edgartown Commons boasts an ideal location within walking distance to downtown Edgartown's shops, restaurants, and attractions. It's also conveniently located near the bus stop, making it easy to access beaches and other parts of the island without a car.
💡 Practical Tips
The staff is frequently praised for being accommodating, friendly, and helpful. The presence of free parking is also a plus, although some mention that parking can be limited. Check-in and check-out processes are described as easy.
⚠️ Things to Consider
A few recent reviews mention issues with spiders and cleanliness in specific units, alongside concerns about rude management. Some guests have also noted uncomfortable mattresses and a lack of AC in certain living areas during hot weather.
Hotel Amenities
✨Other Amenities(25)
🏊Pool & Water(4)
🛎️Services(4)
Browse more family hotels by amenity
Family Activities Near Edgartown Commons
Kid-friendly attractions and things to do nearby
Edgartown Lighthouse
A picturesque landmark offering scenic views and a glimpse into maritime history, perfect for a family stroll.
South Beach
A popular, expansive beach known for its surf and dunes, ideal for a day of sun, sand, and swimming.
Martha's Vineyard Museum
Explore the island's rich history and culture through engaging exhibits that can appeal to various age groups.
Ocean Park
A beautiful green space in Edgartown perfect for picnics, playing, and enjoying the island atmosphere.
Bike Rentals
Rent bikes to explore Edgartown and the island's scenic bike paths, a favorite activity for many families.
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions from families about Edgartown Commons
Are cribs available?▼
Is parking free?▼
When is the pool open?▼
What are check-in and check-out times?▼
Are there any complaints I should know about?▼
More Family Hotels in Martha's Vineyard
Explore other top-rated family-friendly hotels nearby

Faraway Martha's Vineyard
Families love this hotel because: walkable Edgartown location by the harbor, free bikes to borrow, a heated saltwater pool plus hot tub, and suites with separate living rooms.
Based on 50 reviews (15 family reviews)

Harbor View Hotel
Families love this hotel because: attentive service at the Bettini restaurant, a walkable location near Edgartown, a heated saltwater outdoor pool (May to October), connecting rooms on request, and free parking.
Based on 50 reviews (17 family reviews)

Madison Inn
Families love this hotel because: it's a short walk from the Oak Bluffs ferry, beach chairs, towels and umbrellas are free to borrow, and coffee, fruit, snacks and ice cream are out for guests.
Based on 50 reviews (25 family reviews)

Vineyard Square Hotel & Suites
Families love this hotel because: walkable Edgartown location near shops and restaurants, breakfast included, free onsite parking (reserve ahead), bicycles available, and in-room refrigerators.
Based on 50 reviews (14 family reviews)

Mansion House
Families love this hotel because: an indoor pool that two reviewers say their kids loved, a rooftop deck, a short walk to the Vineyard Haven ferry, and interconnected rooms plus highchairs available.
Based on 50 reviews (12 family reviews)

The Lightkeepers Inn
Families love this hotel because: suites with kitchenettes and separate living rooms, sofa beds for kids, an easy walk to Edgartown shops, restaurants and ice cream, beach chairs and towels provided, and very clean rooms
Based on 50 reviews (14 family reviews)