
Open Hearth Lodge
What Makes This Hotel Stand Out
Several reviewers single out the outdoor gathering spaces: fire pits, a large lawn and yard games like corn hole and frisbee. Reviewers also mention board games indoors and a hands-on owner family who greet guests personally.
Parent Pro Tip
Book early if you need two beds. One guest who reserved months ahead still couldn't get two queens and got a king plus a pull-out instead. If you need more space, call the number on your booking confirmation to request connecting rooms, which are subject to availability.
Why Families Love This Hotel
Families love this hotel because: heated indoor pool and hot tub, free continental breakfast, outdoor fire pits and lawn games like corn hole, friendly family-run management, and free parking.
Open Hearth Lodge is a highly recommended family-friendly destination in Door County, particularly praised for its exceptional service, pet-friendliness, and array of amenities. Families seeking a comfortable, clean, and engaging stay will find it a welcoming choice.
Best for: Ideal for families looking for a pet-friendly getaway with numerous on-site activities and welcoming staff in Door County.
At a Glance
Free breakfast and parking plus low-cost cribs make this a solid value, and two reviewers called the prices affordable or reasonable, though opinions on the breakfast range from excellent to modest.
Room Setup
The lodge offers a variety of room setups, including suites with pocket doors, king rooms, and family rooms, providing good options for families.
Kids Features
Families can enjoy the indoor heated pool, which is a significant draw for children.
Family Dining
Breakfast is included and generally well-received, with mention of a "conveyor pancake maker" and good choices.
Location
The lodge is conveniently located outside of the main town bustle, offering a quiet setting while still being close to Door County attractions like Sister Bay and the Door County Auditorium.
Map Location — Open Hearth Lodge
2669 S Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay, WI 54234-9160
The lodge offers a wide range of activities and amenities suitable for all age groups, from toddlers enjoying the pool to teenagers appreciating the social aspects like fire pits and board games.
Detailed Family Analysis for Open Hearth Lodge
Our AI has analyzed 50 family reviews to give you detailed insights about what makes this hotel great for families.
🏆 Overall Family Assessment
Open Hearth Lodge is a highly recommended family-friendly destination in Door County, particularly praised for its exceptional service, pet-friendliness, and array of amenities. Families seeking a comfortable, clean, and engaging stay will find it a welcoming choice.
🏨 Room Setup & Space
The lodge offers a variety of room setups, including suites with pocket doors, king rooms, and family rooms, providing good options for families. Suites are noted for being large with comfortable beds and couches, offering ample space for families to relax. Many rooms feature refrigerators, which is a practical amenity for families with young children.
🎯 Kids' Amenities
Families can enjoy the indoor heated pool, which is a significant draw for children. The availability of board games, puzzles, and an outdoor area with games like cornhole provides additional entertainment options for kids. The dog park and dog wash are unique amenities that families with pets will appreciate.
🍽️ Family Dining
Breakfast is included and generally well-received, with mention of a "conveyor pancake maker" and good choices. While there are no explicit mentions of kids' menus or kitchenettes in standard rooms, the availability of refrigerators in rooms and picnic areas suggests some flexibility for families preparing their own snacks or light meals.
✨ Cleanliness & Safety
Cleanliness is consistently highlighted as a strong point by guests. Rooms are described as very clean, sparkling clean, and well-maintained. This attention to detail contributes to a comfortable and reassuring stay for families.
📍 Location & Attractions
The lodge is conveniently located outside of the main town bustle, offering a quiet setting while still being close to Door County attractions like Sister Bay and the Door County Auditorium. Its location is considered ideal for day-tripping to various points of interest in the peninsula.
💡 Practical Tips
The staff and owners are frequently praised for being outstanding, friendly, welcoming, and accommodating, often going above and beyond. Free parking is available, and the lodge's accessibility features are noted. Some guests experienced issues with room availability when booking, highlighting the importance of booking in advance.
⚠️ Things to Consider
A few reviews mentioned issues with booking specifics, such as not getting the desired bed configuration. There were also a couple of negative reviews concerning lost items and refund policies, which parents should be aware of. While overwhelmingly positive, these isolated incidents suggest checking policies and confirming details when booking.
Hotel Amenities
✨Other Amenities(22)
🛎️Services(5)
🏊Pool & Water(4)
Browse more family hotels by amenity
Family Activities Near Open Hearth Lodge
Kid-friendly attractions and things to do nearby
Sister Bay Marina
Enjoy boat watching, a playground, and scenic views along the waterfront.
Peninsula State Park
Offers hiking, biking, scenic overlooks, a lighthouse, and beaches.
Edgewood Orchard Gallery
A unique art gallery set in a beautiful orchard, with sculptures in its gardens.
Door County Creamery
Farmstead offering goat cheese, ice cream, and a chance to see farm animals.
Big Easy Oyster Bar & Grill
Family-friendly dining option in Sister Bay with live music and a relaxed atmosphere.
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions from families about Open Hearth Lodge
Are cribs available?▼
Is breakfast included?▼
Is parking free?▼
What are the check-in and check-out times?▼
Can we bring our dog?▼
More Family Hotels in Door County
Explore other top-rated family-friendly hotels nearby

Newport Resort
Families love this hotel because: two-bedroom suites with full kitchens, an indoor pool plus a seasonal outdoor pool, an indoor play area for kids, and a walkable spot near Egg Harbor shops and restaurants.
Based on 50 reviews (24 family reviews)

High Point Inn
Families love this hotel because: indoor pool plus seasonal outdoor pool, multi-bedroom suites with kitchens, a playground, free parking, and up to 2 kids 13 and under stay free per adult.
Based on 50 reviews (19 family reviews)

Waterbury Inn
Families love this hotel because: suites with in-room kitchens, indoor and outdoor pools plus a hot tub, rooms reviewers call spotless, and friendly staff with coffee and hot chocolate in the lobby.
Based on 50 reviews (25 family reviews)

Ephraim Motel
Families love this hotel because: free daily breakfast, a fenced seasonal heated pool, a playground and bikes, spotless rooms, and mini golf just across the street.
Based on 50 reviews (20 family reviews)

Edgewater Resort
Families love this hotel because: spacious suites with full kitchens, a seasonal outdoor pool, private beach access, and a walkable spot next to The Old Post Office Restaurant.
Based on 50 reviews (10 family reviews)

Westwood Shores Waterfront Resort
Families love this hotel because: spacious 2-bedroom suites with full kitchens, indoor and outdoor pools, bay views and sunsets from the balconies, spotless grounds, and up to 2 kids 12 and under stay free.
Based on 50 reviews (23 family reviews)