
The Lodge at Leathem Smith
What Makes This Hotel Stand Out
Reviewers highlight the location by the water, including water views and a casual tiki bar out front. Some guests also praised suites with a kitchenette and living room. Reviews of room condition are sharply divided, though, and repeated complaints about musty smells and dirty rooms are common.
Parent Pro Tip
When booking, ask which building your room is in and request a suite. The most positive reviews describe suites with a kitchenette and living room, while at least three negative reviews describe rooms in the 'Fisherman Village' or 'Fishing Village' area.
Why Families Love This Hotel
Families love this hotel because: free cribs, free continental breakfast 7–10 AM, suites with kitchenettes, an outdoor pool, and free onsite parking.
The Lodge at Leathem Smith offers spacious suites and a charming atmosphere with water views, making it appealing for families seeking a unique stay. However, potential guests should be aware of consistent complaints about the dated condition of some rooms and inconsistent cleanliness.
Best for: Families looking for spacious accommodations and a charming, slightly rustic experience in Door County.
At a Glance
Value is mixed: free breakfast, parking and cribs help, but many reviewers felt the dated, sometimes musty or unclean rooms didn't justify the rates. Some guests called it an affordable Door County option.
Room Setup
The Lodge at Leathem Smith offers a variety of room configurations, including suites with kitchenettes and separate living areas, which are ideal for families needing extra space.
Kids Features
The hotel features an outdoor pool, which some guests found to be too cold to use.
Family Dining
The lodge has a restaurant and bar/lounge, and offers a breakfast included with made-to-order options.
Location
Located in Door County, WI, the lodge offers proximity to Sturgeon Bay and scenic water views.
Map Location — The Lodge at Leathem Smith
1640 Memorial Drive, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235-1504
The suites offer ample space for younger children to move around, and the location is good for family outings. However, the lack of specific infant amenities and potential for outdated room conditions might make it less ideal for families with very young babies.
Detailed Family Analysis for The Lodge at Leathem Smith
Our AI has analyzed 50 family reviews to give you detailed insights about what makes this hotel great for families.
🏆 Overall Family Assessment
The Lodge at Leathem Smith offers spacious suites and a charming atmosphere with water views, making it appealing for families seeking a unique stay. However, potential guests should be aware of consistent complaints about the dated condition of some rooms and inconsistent cleanliness.
🏨 Room Setup & Space
The Lodge at Leathem Smith offers a variety of room configurations, including suites with kitchenettes and separate living areas, which are ideal for families needing extra space. Some rooms feature private balconies and jacuzzis, providing comfort and convenience.
🎯 Kids' Amenities
The hotel features an outdoor pool, which some guests found to be too cold to use. While specific kids' activities or dedicated play areas are not heavily highlighted, the presence of family rooms and suites, along with a generally welcoming atmosphere, caters to families.
🍽️ Family Dining
The lodge has a restaurant and bar/lounge, and offers a breakfast included with made-to-order options. Some reviews mention positive experiences with Sunday brunch and special holiday meals, suggesting potential for family-friendly dining, though one review notes the restaurant is mediocre.
✨ Cleanliness & Safety
Cleanliness is a recurring point of contention, with some guests reporting issues like musty smells, outdated bathrooms, and even finding hairs or stains in rooms. However, other reviews specifically praise the cleanliness and maintenance of the rooms and property.
📍 Location & Attractions
Located in Door County, WI, the lodge offers proximity to Sturgeon Bay and scenic water views. While not directly downtown, it's a short drive to local attractions, shops, and restaurants, making it a convenient base for exploring the area.
💡 Practical Tips
Check-in can be slow, especially during peak times, with long lines reported. Some guests have noted issues with noise from upstairs rooms. While many staff members are praised for being friendly and accommodating, there are also mentions of challenges when issues arise.
⚠️ Things to Consider
The most significant concern is the dated nature of the property, with some rooms described as worn and in need of renovation. Issues like musty smells, outdated decor, and maintenance problems (e.g., dripping faucets, broken fixtures) are mentioned frequently by dissatisfied guests.
Hotel Amenities
✨Other Amenities(36)
🍽️Dining(7)
🛎️Services(4)
Browse more family hotels by amenity
Family Activities Near The Lodge at Leathem Smith
Kid-friendly attractions and things to do nearby
Sturgeon Bay Waterfront
Enjoy a stroll along the waterfront, explore local shops and restaurants, and take in the scenic views of the bay.
Door County Maritime Museum
Discover the rich maritime history of Door County with interactive exhibits and a lighthouse climb.
Potawatomi State Park
Offers hiking trails, picnic areas, and scenic views of Green Bay, perfect for outdoor family fun.
Peninsula State Park
One of Wisconsin's most popular state parks, featuring hiking, biking, swimming, and the iconic Eagle Tower.
Sunset Beach
A nice spot for families to relax, play in the sand, and enjoy the waters of Sturgeon Bay.
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions from families about The Lodge at Leathem Smith
Are cribs available?▼
Is breakfast included?▼
Is parking free?▼
What are the check-in and check-out times?▼
Is the outdoor pool heated?▼
More Family Hotels in Door County
Explore other top-rated family-friendly hotels nearby

Newport Resort
Families love this hotel because: two-bedroom suites with full kitchens, an indoor pool plus a seasonal outdoor pool, an indoor play area for kids, and a walkable spot near Egg Harbor shops and restaurants.
Based on 50 reviews (24 family reviews)

High Point Inn
Families love this hotel because: indoor pool plus seasonal outdoor pool, multi-bedroom suites with kitchens, a playground, free parking, and up to 2 kids 13 and under stay free per adult.
Based on 50 reviews (19 family reviews)

Waterbury Inn
Families love this hotel because: suites with in-room kitchens, indoor and outdoor pools plus a hot tub, rooms reviewers call spotless, and friendly staff with coffee and hot chocolate in the lobby.
Based on 50 reviews (25 family reviews)

Ephraim Motel
Families love this hotel because: free daily breakfast, a fenced seasonal heated pool, a playground and bikes, spotless rooms, and mini golf just across the street.
Based on 50 reviews (20 family reviews)

Edgewater Resort
Families love this hotel because: spacious suites with full kitchens, a seasonal outdoor pool, private beach access, and a walkable spot next to The Old Post Office Restaurant.
Based on 50 reviews (10 family reviews)

Westwood Shores Waterfront Resort
Families love this hotel because: spacious 2-bedroom suites with full kitchens, indoor and outdoor pools, bay views and sunsets from the balconies, spotless grounds, and up to 2 kids 12 and under stay free.
Based on 50 reviews (23 family reviews)